Einstein's Method
A scholarly inquiry...
This book examines a method Einstein used extensively and applies it to current problems in QM and relativity.
 
  » Home
  » His Method
  » Introduction
  » Chapter II
  » Chapter III
  » Later Chapters
  » Index
  » The Author
  » Purchase
  » Comments/Discussion
Email the author, or post comments. Include your email address (which won't be posted) if you would like a reply.

Comments may be edited for clarity and will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

Comment: Is your whole book written as a Socratic dialogue? Why did you choose to do so?
Reply: The Foreword, which doubles as an introduction, and a short essay on Einstein and his method are not in dialog form. When you must explain and defend many new ideas a question and answer format works well as Galileo showed in his famous dialog that advanced the Copernican theory.
Comment [from the Amazon review]: "...Klevgard has written the seminal snapshot of a core analysis of quantum and relative physics, from an intuitive ontological point of view. [It]...explain[s] what's been missing in quantum uncertainty..."
Comment: Is the uncertainty principle the basis for all of quantum mechanics?

Reply: Heisenberg certainly thought so, whereas Bohr thought the wave-particle duality was more fundamental. Both were original thinkers, but as I point out in my book, both are open to criticism from the point of view of ontology (what exists and what occurs).

Bohr and countless others treat the particle as the conjugal opposite of a wave whereas a particle is an existing material entity/object and a wave is a form and not an entity. The opposite of the waveform (i.e., the form radiation possesses) is the field form (i.e., the form matter possesses); instances of one occur and progress in space, instances of the other exist and progress in time.

As for Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, it is basically limited to projectile motion such as moving electrons. The uncertainty relation does not apply to space-stationary matter, for example. Such matter has zero momentum so it is foolish to quantify an uncertainty-of-momentum for a particle that has no momentum in the first place. The equivalent is to quantify the uncertainty of the photon’s rest mass.
The uncertainty principle and wave-field duality can both be traced back to ontology: mass and energy entities, field and wave forms, and existence and occurrence categories.